Carova, NC Outer Banks Real Estate

How accurate is a Zillow Zestimate on the Outer Banks?

Everyone talks about them. Some buyers want to make their offers based on them. But just how accurate is a Zestimate offer by Zillow? 

I think that has to do a lot with the old real estate adage "Location, Location, Location". While a Zestimate might be fairly accurate for a house in a full-time residential community of hundreds of similar house and usually only 4-5 different models, on the Outer Banks it is a completely different story.

On the Outer Banks of North Carolina distance from the beach plays an important role. So much so that in some case just crossing the street and drop a properties value by as much as 50%. This makes things very challenging for a computerized valuation model trying to come up with a price looking at sold comps within a 1 mile radius. Even Zillow recognizes that there calculations may be flawed. To show this I pulled up my own house in Carova Beach. Like any other property, Zillow gave me a nice solid Zestimate number in the top left hand corner of the page where it could be easily found. But, buried down deeper in the page is the hidden truth. About halfway down the page that Zestimate number pops up again only this time they are giving a range of their accuracy along with it. In my case that range was a spread of $143,000.

My God! You could fit another house in there!

In my world you you mis price a house by $143,000 you are likely to either have it sold in the first week or it is going to sit for the next year. In the end if you are planning on buying or selling a property on the Outer Banks skip Zillow and find yourself a knowledgeable local REALTOR to give you the real numbers.



Zillow Zestimate

Jean-Paul Peron
Living & Working in 4-Wheel Drive
The Outer Banks Real Estate Company
Work:  (888) 457-7376
Mobile: (252) 564-9390


Comment balloon 4 commentsJean-Paul Peron • March 25 2014 03:28AM
How accurate is a Zillow Zestimate on the Outer Banks?
Everyone talks about them. Some buyers want to make their offers based on them. But just how accurate is a Zestimate offer by Zillow? I think that has to do a lot with the old real estate adage "Location, Location, Location". While… more
I will not be using a Buyer Broker - Just take the 3% off the price
I have not done a "Re-Blog" in a long time, but this article is so good on two parts. One - the nievity of some clients. We cannot always assume that evey buyer (or seller) knows how buying & selling real estate works although we… more
Just how does "Due Diligence" work?
I find myself trying to explain this one a lot. After much trial & error, I think I have have figured out the best way to put it. The story goes like this… In the old days you would write your offer for a certain purchase price and… more
Two Words Every Outer Banks NC Home Buyer and Seller Should Know
I was on my way to writing a blog post about the changes to the NC "Offer to Purchase " contracts and the new "Due Diligence " clause. Then I ran across this one by Charlotte agent Carol Fox, and thought "Why… more
This blog rings so true to me. I always cringe when a buyer wants to shop by square footage. In my experience what is really important is knowing the size of the rooms, not the whole house. I have been in many 1, 500 sq/ft houses that had… more